Protecting Your Legacy
We provide personal and commercial insurance, tailored to protect what matters most.
Our Services
Customized coverage for your home, vehicles, and business, with ongoing guidance from an independent agency you can trust.
About Matthews Legacy Agency
At Matthews Legacy Agency, we believe insurance should be straightforward, not overwhelming. As an independent agency, we work with trusted insurance carriers to help you find coverage that fits your needs. Whether for your home, vehicles, or business, we focus on clear guidance, personalized solutions, and dependable service.
Matthews Legacy Agency represents more than a name—it reflects a family history in the insurance business. Jeffrey Matthews began his insurance career in 2005, following in the footsteps of his father, Jim, whose career spanned more than four decades. His sister, Theresa, also became part of that insurance tradition, further strengthening the family’s connection to the industry. Those experiences helped shape the values behind Matthews Legacy Agency: straightforward guidance, dependable service, and relationships built on trust. Today, Jeffrey carries that tradition forward through an agency created to continue the Matthews family legacy.
Why Choose Matthews Legacy Agency?
Independent Agency
Personalized Service
Responsive Support
We work with trusted carriers to help you compare coverage options and choose protection that fits your needs.
Personal attention and clear guidance throughout the insurance process.
We're here to answer your questions and provide ongoing support whenever your insurance needs change.